Here it was, the Return of the Jedi episode of Lost. Desmond and Charlie on the moon of Endor (the Looking Glass station), trying to knock down the Empire's force fields (er, jamming frequency), while Sayid, Bernard and Jin do the air (beach) battle and Jack et. al. have one last confrontation with the Darth Vader (Ben).
But that's not we're all wondering about, is it?
I loved the site of Jim Morrison-era Jack - bearded, bloated and drugged out. The entire show I tried to figure out where in the timeline this was - before/after he went to Thailand? Sometime around 1993, hence the blaring Nirvana ("Scentless Apprentice")? My girlfriend even pointed out Jack's cell KRZR phone was an anachronism - but it still didn't dawn on me. We're in the future - sometime after the events of the island we've been following for three seasons. This was the turning the show on its head moment I've been hoping for.
But it was terribly, terribly sad. Life post mysterious island has not treated the Shepard kindly, now that he no longer has his flock to lead. He spends his weekends flying on free Oceanic air mileage, hoping his plane will crash. Ben and Locke we're right all along, it seems - they weren't supposed to leave. He knows it too (we can assume that those maps in his home were island-related). I can't begin to speculate what's s happened between the scene at the radio tower and Jack's meeting Kate at the airport. That scene was both heartbreaking and mystifying at once. What's he “tired of lying” about? Who does she have to get back to? Whose funeral did no one attend to? Why do Jack and Kate seem so distant from each other? Is Kate still a fugitive? In the hospital Jack says that he’s not as drunk as his father is upstairs – does that mean he’s alive (Jack also claims his dad wrote him an Oxycontin prescription, but that he’s “out of town”)? Why was the naturally beautifully Kate covered in make-up? All questions that'll have to wait till January, 2008.
I'm going to miss Charlie. I hoped he wasn’t going to die. I thought he’d play his keypad version of Good Vibrations, save the day, and avoid drowning. Of all the characters, he had gone through the greatest transformation, from washed up, junkie rock star to family man and hero. Even when he only had moments to live, after Mikhail launches a grenade to flood his room with water, Charlie used his last remaining moments to warn Desmond that Naomi was not sent by Penny.
We all knew Hurley was going to save the day, but I didn’t see the return of the Volks Wagon van. I also didn’t see Sawyer killing Tom (aka Mr. Friendly) after he’d surrendered. The warm and fuzzy Sawyer (i.e., Han Solo) of season 3 is truly no more. Very well done.
The return of Walt was a welcomed surprise, puberty victim hood and all (yet still wearing the same kid clothes - my friend Dan recently theorized they removed Walt from the show because the writers would be unable to explain his rapid physical transformation). We don’t know whether he was the actual Walt or merely in Locke’s mind. Whatever the case, with Ben Linus having killed too many of his own people, now tied up and beaten to a bloody pulp, the ascension of Locke as the new master of the Island is clear. He even kills the mysterious Naomi, but is unable to shoot Jack. Speaking of Naomi, if Penny did not send her then who did? Why was she carrying a picture of Desmond? Perhaps Penny’s father, Charles Widmore, sent her.
There are more questions and observations, of course, but I’ve run out of time. I’ll pick up the slack later with comments.